AC
Circuit Problem - 4 - Notes on the Problem - 1
Circuit4P04
You were asked to examine this circuit (below) in two different ways.
-
You built this circuit
in the laboratory, and explored what went on.
-
You should have found
that this circuit "emphasizes" a band of frequencies around a "resonant"
frequency.
-
That is the same kind
of frequency behavior that you found in the RLC circuit you examined earlier.
-
That's this circuit (below)
-

-
So, you should reasonably
expect that the frequency response function (i.e. Vo/Vin)
should be of the same general form. And any insight that you have
generated for the RLC circuit should carry over to the op-amp circuit above.
-
You were asked to analyze
the circuit so that you could calculate various aspects of the performance
of this circuit. Those aspects include the following.
-
The resonant frequency
- i.e. the frequency at which the peak response occurs. You were
able to do that for the RLC circuit, and should be able to get this one
- but you have to be able to analyze the circuit and get that frequency
response function.
-
The bandwidth - this is
more of a challenge for you. You have to define the problem - i.e.
figure out what it is that you are looking for - and then apply your mathematical
skills to get a solution. The hard part of this problem seems to
be to realize that you are looking at when the magnitude of the frequency
response function drops to 0.707 of the value at the resonant peak.
You have to get that magnitude thing in there, and that means that you
better understand the idea of the magnitude of a complex number.
-
The gain at the resonant
frequency is also important. You should be able to calculate that.
It will be different for the two different circuits.
We can work on this together.
-
First, we will put together
a quick list of the things that you need to do. Click
here for E. J.'s list.
-
Secondly, we need to think
about what we should look for in all of this.
-
IMPORTANT ITEM #1
here is that you can make predictions for several of the circuit performance
measures - resonant frequency, bandwidth and gain at the resonant frequency.
-
IMPORTANT ITEM #2 is that
you have laboratory measurements that you can compare to your predictions.
-
A short philosophical
note on items 1 & 2: Making predictions is what engineers do.
If you are designing a spacecraft or an airplane, you need to predict how
it will function. If your predictions are off when someone finally
rides in your vehicle you won't have a job for very long because you may
have killed someone. Making correct predictions is the most important
thing that you do as an engineer. The second most important thing
is to be able to communicate those predictions effectively. The engineers
at Three Mile Island made correct predictions but failed to communicate
clearly. You MUST get both of those correct.
-
Your report should include
the following.
-
Predictions of performance
measures
-
Measurements of performance
measures
-
Comparison of predictions
and measurements
-
Explanation - as best
possible - of discrepancies. You need to explain discrepancies analytically
(i.e. show where your analysis and physical reality do not match up) and
numerically (i.e. show that a corrected analysis would yield the numerical
results you actually obtained).
-
IMPORTANT ITEM #3 is that
you need to learn how to anticipate where your analysis and model might
not be as trustworthy as you would like. There is at least one problem
in one of the two circuits, and it is the kind of problem that you need
to learn about - i.e. a model that doesn't match up with reality as well
as you might like.