Project Six Resource Page: Dissections

Evolution Resources Safety Resources Field Trip Resources

Should Dissections be Used for Instructional Purposes:
If So, When?

Resources on the Internet:

American Physiological Society [http://www.faseb.org/aps/educate.html] Click on this site maintained by the APS and follow through their links to their policy statement and advice to teachers.

The Use of Animals in Biology Education [http://www.uc.twsu.edu/~obswww/nabt.html] This site is the location of a short statement issued by the National Association of Biology Teachers in 1995 regarding this organizations position on the use of animals in the biology classroom.

People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals [http://www.envirolink.org/arrs/peta/index.html] PETA is the largest animal rights organization in the world. "PETA is dedicated to establishing and protecting the rights of all animals. PETA operates under the simple principle that animals are not ours to eat, wear, experiment on, or use for entertainment."

American Anti-Vivisection Society [http://www.aavs.org/] This is the homepage of a society whose goals are to end vivisection.

Americans for Medical Progress [http://www.ampef.org/index.html] This is the homepage of a society formed to counteract the influrence of PETA and protect the right to use animals in research.

Selected Bibliography:

Adkins, J. and R. Lock. 1994. Using Animals in Secondary Education - A Pilot Survey. Journal of Biological Education 28: 48-52.

Allchin, D. 1991. Dissecting Classroom Ethics. Science Teacher 58: 44-49.

Baier, S.W. 1993. The Impact of Animal Rights on the Use of Animals for Biomedical Research, Product Testing & Education. American Biology Teacher 55: 136-139.

Breo, D. 1990. Animal Rights vs Research? A Question of the Nation's Scientific Literacy. Journal of the American Medical Association 264: 2564-2565.

Buyukmihci, N.C. The Issue of Dissection [http://www.envirolink.org/arrs/avar/dissect.htm#BOF]

Cantor, D. 1992. Animals Don't Belong in School. American School Board Journal 179: 39-40.

Gilmore, D.R. 1991. Politics & Prejudice: Dissection in Biology Education. Part I. American Biology Teacher 53: 211-213.

Gilmore, D.R. 1991. Politics & Prejudice: Dissection in Biology Education Part II. American Biology Teacher 53: 272-274.

Hairston, R.W. ed. 1990. The Responsible Use of Animals in Biology Classrooms Including Alternatives to Dissection. Monograph IV. 162p. National Association of Biology Teachers

Holden, C. 1990. Animal Rights Activism Threatens Dissection. Science 250: 751

Keiser, T., and R. Hamm. 1991. Forum: Dissection -- The Case For. Science Teacher 58: 13-15.

Kinzie, M.B., R. Strauss and M.J. Foss. 1993. The Effects of Interactive Dissection Simulation on the Performance and Achievement of High School Biology Students. Journal of Research in Science Teaching 30: 989-1000.

Kinzie, M.B., M.J. Foss and S.M. Powers. 1993. Use of Dissection-Related Courseware by Low-Ability High School Students: A Qualitative Inquiry. Educational Technology Research and Development 41: 87-101.

Kinzie, M.B., V.A. Larsen, J.B. Burch, and S.M. Boker. 1996. Frog Dissection via the World Wide Web: Implications for Widespread Delivery of Instruction. Educational Technology Research and Development 44: 59-69.

Lock, R. 1995. GCSE Students' Attitudes to Dissection and Using Animals in Research and Product Testing. School Science Review 77: 279: 15-21.

Lord, T. 1994. College Students' Opinions about Animal Dissections. Journal of College Science Teaching 23: 267-

Mayer, V.J., and N.K. Hinton. 1990. Animals in the Classroom: Considering the Options. Science Teacher 57: 26-30.

McInerney, J.D. 1993. Animals in education: Are We Prisoners of False Sentiment? American Biology Teacher 55: 276-277.

Morrison, A.R. 1992. What's Wrong with "Animal Rights"? American School Board Journal 179: 20-23.

Morrison, A. 1993. Biomedical Research and the Animal Rights Movement: A Contrast in Values. American Biology Teacher 55: 204-208.

NSTA (National Science Teacher's Association) [http://www.nsta.org] Planning and Managing Dissection Laboratories. Florida Association of Science Teachers.

Offner, S. 1993. The Importance of Dissection in Biology Teaching. American Biology Teacher 55: 147-149.

Orlans, F.B. 1988. Should Students Harm or Destroy Animal Life? American Biology Teacher 50: 6-12.

Orlans, F.B. 1991. Forum: Dissection -- The Case Against. Science Teacher 58: 12-14.

Orlans, F.B. 1991. Use of Animals in Education: Policy and Practice in the United States. Journal of Biological Education 25: 27-32.

Richmond, G., M Engelmann, and L.R. Krupka. The Animal Research Controversy. American Biology Teacher 52: 467-471.

Riechard, D.E. 1993. Teaching Science: The Dissection Dilemma. Clearing House 67: 4-5.

Smith, W. 1994. Use of Animals and Animal Organs in Schools: Practice and Attitudes of Teachers. Journal of Biological Education 28: 111-118.

Strauss, R.T., and M.B. Kinzie. 1994. Student Achievement & Attitudes in a Pilot Study Comparing an Interactive Videodisc Simulation to Conventional Dissection. American Biology Teacher 56: 398-402.

Strauss, R.T., and M.B. Kinzie. 1991. Hi-Tech Alternatives to Dissection. 1991. American Biology Teacher 53: 154-158.

Trotter, A. 1992. Animal Rights Groups Target High School Dissection. American School Board Journal 179: 22-23.